CONTENT POSTMORTEM · A PUBLISHED CLAIM Review date: November 10, 2026. This record reviews the Machine House essay and case study about The Masoom Minawala Show. What was published On September 6, the catalogue export showed 2,394,331 views for January 1–September 3, 2025 and 4,664,058 for the same dates in 2026. The reported change was 94.8%. Both years used the same list of 84 show videos. Personal uploads and Shorts were excluded; sponsored episodes and older releases were in scope. Why the wording was under review The 2026 window crossed YouTube’s August 24 public counting change. A September 9 essay kept the original arithmetic and identified the comparison it could not yet defend in a sponsor pitch. What settled it The November 10 report requested engaged views for the same videos and dates. The two totals were 2,394,330 and 4,560,858. The independently requested video rows and daily rows both added up to those totals. Growth on this definition was 90.5%. The general views column for 2026 had also moved to 4,696,261 by November, so the difference from the September headline cannot all be assigned to the counting change. Closed action Machine House changed the case-study metric and FAQ to 90.5% more engaged views and added a dated postscript to the original essay. The historical watch-hour result kept its own retrieval date. A reviewer can close the correction when the live tile, FAQ and postscript all identify the same metric, cohort and windows. Open question for a sponsorship A count for the entire catalogue cannot establish how many people watched a particular host read. Ask for that video’s retention around the integration and the advertising traffic separately. Keep that question open until those records exist. Live case: https://machinehouse.media/work/masoom-minawala#metrics Dated essay and source definitions: https://machinehouse.media/writing/youtube-changed-what-a-view-means Blank release review: https://machinehouse.media/resources/editorial-decisions/postmortem-template.txt